Are you stumped on what to put in a baby Easter basket? These baby Easter basket ideas will guide you on how to create the perfect “My First Easter” basket for your precious baby. [*Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission For items purchased at no additional cost to you. Read the full disclosure here.]
If you’re a new parent or have a new addition to your family, celebrating your baby’s first Easter is an extra special milestone! Easter is a wonderful time to celebrate new beginnings and create special memories with your sweet baby. Even if your baby won’t be participating in the Easter egg hunt this year, a thoughtfully-curated Easter basket can still bring plenty of joy and introduce them to the fun of the holiday. Here are some creative baby Easter basket ideas and product recommendations to help you make the perfect baby Easter basket! Need ideas for toddlers? Check out my non candy Easter basket ideas for toddlers!
Baby Easter Basket Ideas:
Babies are all about exploring textures, sounds, and colors. Choose items that are soft, safe, and stimulating for your little one’s senses.
1. Soft and Cuddly Plush Toys:
A cuddly bunny, lamb, or chick is a timeless addition to any baby’s basket. Opt for adorable plush bunnies, chicks, or lambs designed with soft, baby-friendly materials.
- Itzy Crinkle Lovey Bunny: This bunny lovey is super soft and adorable! It has Crinkle arms and feet and a silicone teether. Plushies with crinkle components are great sensory options. Babies love the satisfying crinkly sound!
- Gund Baby Flora Singing Bunny: This adorable soft bunny plays music and plays peekaboo! This sweet bunny is sure to delight your little one.
- Mary Meyer Oatmeal Bunny: This super cute bunny is soft and has an understuffed body. The satin ears provide another sensory element for your baby to explore.
- Mary Meyer Nursery Lamb: A super adorable little lamb, perfect for Easter.
2. Board Books and Soft Books:
Choose sturdy board books featuring Easter themes or springtime animals, or soft books that have crinkly elements and teethers. High contrast books are also perfect for newborns.
- Guess How Much I love You: This is a soft, interactive version of the classic. Babies will love the teething ring. It even has a button that says, “I love you”.
- Babies Love Easter: This chunky lift-a-flap book is a perfect addition to a baby Easter basket. It has sturdy flaps and cute illustrations!
- Soft Peter Rabbit book: This version of the classic is soft with crinkle pages. It also has a teething corner and teething ring!
- Baby Touch and Feel-Bunny: Your baby will love exploring the touch and feel elements on all of the pages. The photos of real bunnies are also adorable!
- Touch and Feel Tummy Time Book: This high contrast cloth book is perfect for newborns. It features touch and feel elements, baby safe mirror, is double sided, and can stand on its own, making it perfect for tummy time.
- Never Touch a Grumpy Bunny: Your baby will love exploring all the different textures in this adorable rhyming book. Perfect book for a baby Easter basket.
3. Teethers:
Babies are constantly teething, so include a fun and safe teether in their basket. Include teething toys made from safe, BPA-free materials to soothe your baby’s gums.
- Infantino Lil Nibblers Carrot teether: This textured teether is BPA free and has lots of bumpies to help soothe sore gums. It also has handles so your baby can easily hold it.
- Mushie Silicone Bunny Teether: This cute bunny teether is BPA Free and has multiple textures to soothe sore gums. The design makes it easy for little holds to hold.
- Taggies Teether Baby Rattle Bunny: This cute bunny has a bumpy silicone teether ring and tags for baby to teethe on. It also doubles as a rattle!
4. Personalized Keepsakes and Keepsake Items:
Commemorate this special first Easter with items you can cherish for years to come.
- Personalized Easter basket: A basket with your baby’s name adds a beautiful touch. We had this one for our baby’s First Easter and plan to use it every year! It’s soft, adorable, and you can choose from 3 different styles.
- My First Easter Basket: This personalized Easter basket is also an adorable toy! It comes with a cute plush bunny, baby chick, egg, and carrot. My First Easter is embroidered on and can be customized with your baby’s name.
- Keepsake stuffed animal: A plush bunny with the year embroidered is a sweet memento for your baby to have as they grow. Customize this one with the year or your baby’s name.
5. Rattles and noise-making toys:
Soft rattles and squeak toys stimulate baby’s hearing and help them learn about cause and effect.
- Crotchet Bunny Wooden Baby Rattle: All Natural wood and cotton this adorable rattle is a great addition to the baby Easter basket.
- Newborn Soft Barn Farm: This is one of our favorites! This barn and farm animals are so cute! All of the animals are soft rattles and make a pleasant rattling sound. The donkey also squeaks. There’s even a baby safe mirror on one side of the barn. My toddler still loves this toy!
- Bearington Soft Easter Bunny Rattle: This adorable soft bunny Rattle is so cute and huggable! It’s soft, light, and makes a light, pleasant rattling sound. A perfect addition to a baby easter basket!
- Skip Hop Baby Egg Maracas: Each of these woodland egg shakers makes a different sound that your baby will love exploring! Sturdy and perfect for little hands.
6. Soft Blankie or Loveys:
Wrap your baby in cozy comfort with a soft blanket or lovey featuring Easter-themed designs or pastel colors. Look for blankets made from breathable fabrics like organic cotton or bamboo.
- Carters Plush Stuffed Animal Snuggler: My baby loves this adorable bunny lovey! It is so soft and plush, and perfect for snuggling. My toddler still loves it!
- Bunny Baby Security Blanket: This super cute bunny lovey is a great option for a baby Easter basket. It has a smooth satin edge to give your baby another soothing texture to explore.
7. Baby Sensory Toys:
Stimulate your baby’s senses with engaging toys that incorporate different textures, colors, and sounds.
- Munchkin Float and Play Bubbles: Make bath time more fun with these floating bath bubbles. These will be sure to entertain your baby as they bobble In the water, spin and rattle.
- Haba Bunny Ball: This adorable bunny ball is perfect for a baby Easter basket! It has textured fabric and crinkle ears, giving your baby so many areas to feel and explore. It also has a teething ring and rattling sound.
- Magic Year’s Farm Finger Puppets: These finger puppets are so cute and perfect for little hands. They are a soft plastic making them great to teethe on. My toddler still loves these and plays with them all the time! They can also be played with in the bath.
Additional Tips:
- Don’t overfill a baby Easter basket: Too many items can overwhelm babies. Focus on a few special things they’ll truly enjoy.
- Consider the basket itself: Choose a basket made of soft materials for your baby’s safety. Soft, personalized baskets can be reused year after year.
- Have fun! Creating your baby’s first Easter basket should be a joyful experience. Embrace the milestone by curating a baby Easter basket that reflects your baby’s interests and developmental level.
As you prepare to celebrate your baby’s first Easter, remember that the most meaningful part of the holiday is the love and joy shared with your little one. Whether you choose to fill their basket with cuddly toys, educational books, or practical essentials, the focus is on creating cherished memories that will last a lifetime. With these creative ideas and product recommendations, you can create a personalized baby Easter basket that delights both baby and parents alike. May this first Easter celebration be filled with love, laughter, and precious memories for you and your family!
Happy Easter and Happy Mommying!
(Disclaimer: Product recommendations are based on my own personal opinion and positive reviews at the time of writing. Always ensure products are age-appropriate and safe for your baby.)
