When we think of Easter eggs, it’s easy to fall into the age-old tradition of stuffing eggs with candy. Candy isn’t always the best option for toddlers however, especially because most candies are still choking hazards for toddlers age 3 and under. This list of the best non-candy Easter egg fillers for toddlers is packed with creative, age-appropriate ideas that are safe, fun, and sure to bring big smiles come Easter morning. There are also so many amazing non-candy Easter basket ideas for toddlers!
[* Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission on items purchased through these links at no additional cost to you. You can read the full disclosure here.]
Inside this post
Table of Contents
Why Choose Non-candy Easter egg fillers for toddlers?
Whether you’re trying to avoid added dyes, added sugar, watching for allergies, safety concerns, or just looking for more creative, play-based ideas, non-candy Easter egg fillers are just as exciting as candy, and way more engaging. Toddlers are still discovering the world through their senses and sugar doesn’t have to be the center of every celebration. We can celebrate the magic of the holidays with other fun items that aren’t candy. I’m not saying you have to or should, avoid all candy for your toddler’s Easter celebration. (We plan on including 1 quality chocolate bunny in our toddler’s Easter basket.) The benefit to non-candy Easter egg fillers though, is that your child can be surprised and excited about what’s inside their eggs without all the extra dyes and sugars that come in candy. Here are some more benefits of non-candy Easter egg fillers:
- Supports fine motor skills and cognitive development
- Encourages exploration, creativity, and independent play
- No sugar crashes
- Allergy friendly
- Creates longer-lasting excitement
- Can be played with over and over again
Tips for Safe Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers for Toddlers
Before we jump into the list, here are a few things to keep in mind when choosing your fillers:
- Watch out for choking hazards, even with small toys that are marketed to toddlers.
- Choose items that are not choking hazards and are too big to be swallowed.
- Look for items with no sharp edges or loose parts.
- Choose developmentally appropriate items for your child.
- Look for non-toxic materials.
Now, let’s dive into this list!
Here are the Best Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers for Toddlers
Toys and Activities
These fun toys are just the right size for toddler hands and Easter eggs:
1. Fisher price little people – There are so many adorable Little People sets to choose from! From Harry Potter and Disney characters to superheros and more!
2. Mini animal figurines (farm, zoo, ocean)
3. Little People Chunky Animals: check out all the different animals below
4. Finger puppets These farm animal fingers puppets are a really great Chunky size!
6. Mini trucks and Hotwheels
7. Chunky, wooden Puzzle pieces (1-2 in each egg) We love Melissa and Doug!
10. Magnamen – a stretchy, magnetic fidget toy
11. Squigz – a suction sensory toy that’s great for motor skills and sensory input.
12. Pop Tubes – We love the large size. These Pop Tubes are a great sensory toy that my toddler consistently playa with!
13. Chunky action figures of favorite characters like:
14. Cute chunky dinosaurs by Little People
15. Mini Fubbles – no spill bubble tumbler, non-toxic
16. Reusable sponge water balls
17. Squishy Bubble ball – a fun fidget toy
What size Easter eggs fit Little People and other chubbier or larger toys you ask?
Large Easter Eggs: These large Easter eggs are such a great size! They can fit small toys but are not too large.
Jumbo Easter Eggs: These jumbo Easter eggs are awesome and can even fit a sippy cup inside!
Arts & Crafts Fillers
Inspire creativity with fun and engaging art supplies.
19. Raindrop crayons
20. No-Spill Finger paint pods
21. Easter stickers
22. Chunky stampers
Practical & Reusable Items
Everyday items can be just as exciting when they’re hidden in colorful Easter eggs:
27. Hair scrunchies
29. Fun toddler animal toothbrush
30. Toddler-friendly jewelry like silicone bracelets
32. Toddler sunglasses -these are polarized and flexible!
Educational Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers for Toddlers
Play and learning go hand-in-hand with these fun and educational Easter egg fillers:
33. Foam letters
34. Foam numbers
35. Animal Magnets with full back
36. Letter fridge magnets -these are a good size and have a full magnetic back+
37. Lit Letters phonics magnets
38. Color sorting counting bears -these are a toddler safe size.
39. Emotional fidget poppers -great for developing social-emotional skills.
40. Felt story and song pieces -my toddler absolutely loves these!
41. DUPLO Legos
42. Mini Magnatiles
43. Translucent letters and numbers -great for light boxes and sensory play.
44. Stacking rocks
45. Mini Tegu blocks -magnetic and amazing for travel!
Non-candy Food Items
50. Mini pretzels
Final Thoughts
As you can see, there are so many non-candy Easter egg options out there. You can fill your toddler’s Easter eggs with engaging, playful, educational, and creative surprises that will lead to a more memorable and meaningful holiday. Plus, most of these ideas are reusable, educational, and promote hands-on learning through play. Toddlers learn best through play. With these non-candy Easter egg fillers for toddlers, you can provide your child with engaging, quality items they can keep playing with and learning from, instead of a candy sugar crash and burn.
Whether you’re doing a full non-candy Easter celebration or mixing in a treat or two, these Easter egg fillers are sure to keep your child’s hands busy and mind engaged. No matter what you put in your toddler’s Easter eggs, remember its all about having fun and creating magical memories. Their smiles and laughs make everything we do as parents worth it.
Looking for more non-candy ideas? Check out these non-candy Easter basket ideas for toddlers!
Need ideas for infants or baby’s first Easter? Take a look at these Easter basket stuffers for babies!
What are your favorite Easter egg fillers for toddlers? Let me know in the comments!
